Territorial Capacity of Local Communities in International Law ; Case Study : Status of Qawasim in Lengeh and Its Impact on the UAE’s Claim on the Three Iranian Islands (Abu Musa and Greater Tunb and Lesser Tunb)

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
The Academy of Sciences of IR Iran
Abstract
Territorial sovereignty of the three Iranian Islands (Abu Musa and Greater Tunb and Lesser Tunb), has been a matter of concern through UAE’s propaganda, particularly in the recent years. The UAE’s legally weak claim, with no compelling evidence and changing straight base line via the artificial islands by this country, has caused severe breaches of certain conventional and customary rules of international law specially since 2022. This article has focused on just one of the multi aspects of UAE’s legal claims with regard to tribal, linguistic, kinship, and religious ties, between Qawasim in Lengeh and Qawasim in Trucial coast. Our findings indicate that Qawasim in Sharjah and Ras Al Khaimah, before 1971: 1) have not had territorial capacity, beyond “shaykhdom” in the lower Persian Gulf region. 2) the presence of Qawasim’s branches in Bandar Lengeh and kangan, is not proving any “territorial ties” with the three Iranian islands (as dependencies of Lengeh). Accordingly, the main question of the article is: whether trucial shaykhs, before establishment of the UAE and transforming to independent State in 1971, had legal capacity for territorial claim on these Islands? In other words, which types of international subjects/entities, under which circumstances have the territorial capacity? – According to jurisprudence of ICJ and other International tribunals, the main argument of the article is: neither general rules of international law nor some criteria which has been made specifically for countries in lower Persian Gulf, support UAE’s claim in respect of the three Iranian islands. In this context, absence of any common institution or establishment, clearly explain complete separation between Qawasim in two sides of the coast . Also, Britain’s role and “special treaty relation”, – particularly 1892 Protection Treaty- entered into force between Britain and shaykhs, has key importance in this case, which has been examined in the article.
Keywords

 
Books
 
·        Brownlie, Ian, international law of fiftieth Anniversary of the united nations. General course on public international law, volume 255, (1995)
 
·        Feldman, David, International Personality , Collected Courses of the Hague Academy of International Law, volume 191, (1985)
 
·        G. Kohen Marcelo, Hébié Mamadou, Research Handbook on Territorial Disputes in International Law, Edward Elgar Publishing, (2018)
 
·        J. Lissitzyn Oliver, Territorial entities other than Independent States in the Law of Treaties, Collected Courses of the Hague Academy of International Law, volume 125, (1968)
 
·        L.O. Buderi Charles, T. Ricart Luciana, The Iran-UAE Gulf Islands Dispute: A journey through International Law, History and Politics, Leiden, Boston: Brill Nijhoff,. Series : Queen Mary Studies in International Law: Volume 29, (2018)
 
 
·        M.Abbott Lucy, The States of the Persian Gulf: From Protectorates to Independent countries, Routledge Handbook of Persian Gulf politicts, edited by Mehran Kamrava, 2020
 
·        Stanislaw Korowicz, Marek, Some Present Aspects of Sovereignty in International Law, Collected Courses of the Hague Academy of International Law, volume 102, (1961)
 
 
·        Vukas, Budislav, states, people and minorities, Collected Courses of the Hague Academy of International Law, volume 231, (1991)
 
 
 
 
Articles
 
E. Beigzadeh, Statut juridique des Trois Iles du Golfe Persique(Abu Musa, Grande Tunb,petite Tunb) a la lumiere de droit et de la jurisprudence internationale, Annuaire du Droit de la Mer, Tome VIII, Institutdu Droit Economique de la Mer, Monaco(France) 2003
 
·        E. Wiegand Krista, Resolution of Border Disputes in the Arabian Gulf, The Journal of Territorial and Maritime Studies , Vol. 1, No. 1, McFarland & Company (2014)
 
·        J. B. Kelly, Sovereignty and Jurisdiction in Eastern Arabia, International Affairs (Royal Institute of International Affairs 1944-) , Jan., 1958, Vol. 34, No. 1 (1958)
 
·        J.B .Kelly, The Buraimi Oasis Dispute, International Affairs (Royal Institute of International Affairs 1944-) , Jul., 1956 , Vol. 32, No. 3 Oxford University Press on behalf of the Royal Institute of International Affairs, ( 1956)
 
·        J. E. Peterson, Tribes and Politics in Eastern Arabia, Middle East Journal , Summer, 1977, Vol. 31, No. 3 (Summer, 1977), pp. 297-312 Published by: Middle East Institute
 
 
 
·        Onley, James, Britain and the Gulf Shaikhdoms, 1820-1971: The Politics Of Protection, Center For International and Regional Studies, Georgetown University School of Foreign Service in Qatar, (2009)
·        P.L.Toye. The Lower Gulf Islands: Abu Musa and The Tunbs:
Vol.1 (1818-1887)
Vol.2 (1888-1908)
Vol.3 (1906-1923)
Vol.4 (1923-1933)
Vol.5 (1934-1935)
Vol.6 (1935-1971)
Archive, edithions, London,1993.
·        R.Schofield, Arabian boundaries, New documents 1963, Iranian Claims to the lower Gulf Islands, Archive, editions, London, 1994.
 
 
Cases
 
·        Dubai-Sharjah Border Arbitration, 19 October 1981
 
 
·        Island of Palmas Case (Netherlands, USA), Reports of International Arbitral Awards,  Volume 2 ,  (1928)
 
 
·        Kasikili/Sedudu Island (Botswana/Namibia), Judgment, ICJ. Reports (1999)
 
·        Land and Maritime Boundary between Cameroon and Nigeria (Cameroon v. Nigeria : Equatorial Guinea intervening) Judgment, ICJ Reports, (2002)
 
·        Legal Status of Eastern Greenland, PCIJ Judgment, (1933 )
 
 
·        Maritime Delimitation and Territorial questions between Qatar and  Bahrain, Merits, Judgment, ICJ, Repots 2001, p. 40
 
·        Reparation for injuries suffered in the service of the United Nation, Advisory opinion, ICJ Reports (1949)
 
·        Rights of Nationals of the United States of America in Morocco, ICJ Reports , Judgment (1952)
 
·        Western Sahara, Advisory Opinion, ICJ, Reports (1975)
 
Volume 4, Issue 7
Humanities
Volume 4, Spring & Summer 2023/2024, No.7
September 2023
Pages 31-65