A New Theory on the Civil Liability of Minors and Mental Patients

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
The Academy of Sciences of IR Iran
Abstract
In this paper, the discussion about the civil liability of minors and mental patients has been discussed in the form of a comparative study, with the descriptive-analytical research method. And this central question has been answered that basically, what criteria should be used to measure the harmful behavior of minors and people with mental disorders?. A look at the history of civil liability clearly indicates that the law of civil liability has always been at a dilemma in answering this question: On the one hand, emotional, moral, fairness and substantive justice issues require the determination or modification of the civil liability of these people, and on the other hand, the final goal of the law of civil liability, i.e. restoring the previous situation and compensating for unjustified losses, complex personal explorations, mental and psychological explorations encountered with serious doubts!. These doubts have caused the legal systems to choose different points of view in this regard: Some have taken the side of the loser and defended the rule of objective criteria in the law of civil liability. And some people are also inclined towards supporting the minor and the insane and have adopted the subjective criterion of fault; Despite this, it seems that we should choose a middle approach and use the " Relative objectivity " criterion as a criterion for evaluating the behavior of minors and patients with mental disorders and based on this, proposed a more flexible and disciplined interpretation of "conventional behavior" in Articles 951 to 953 of the Civil Code.
Keywords

 

1. European Centre of Tort and Insurance Law (2006). Children in Tort Law: Children as Tort Feasors, Vol. 17. Printed in Germany:  Springer Wien NewYork.
2. European Group on Tort Law, Principles of European Tort Law: Text and Commentary (2005). Printed in Austria: Springer Wien NewYork.
3. Harpwood, Vivienne (2009). Modern Tort Law, 7th ed., London and NewYork: Routledge- Cavendish publishing.
4. Stuhmcke, Anita (2001). Essential Tort Law, 2nd ed., London: Cavendish publishing Limited.
5. Van Dam, Cees (2013). European Tort Law, 2nd ed., United Kingdom (UK.): Oxford University Press.
6. Von Bar, Christian, et al. (Ed.). (2009). Principles, Definitions and Model Rules of European Private Law: Draft Common Frame of Reference (DCFR), Prepared by: the Study Group on a European Civil Code & the Research Group on EC Private Law (Acquis Group), Edited by: Christian von Bar, Eric Clive and Hans Schulte-Nölkeand Hugh Beale, Johnny Herre, Jérôme Huet, Matthias Storme, Stephen Swann,Paul Varul, Anna Veneziano and Fryderyk Zoll, Ebook (Six volumes in one volume), sellier. european law publishers, Munich (Germany).
7. Wright, R.George (2017). Objective and Subjective Tests in the Law, Vol.16, Number 1.  The University of New Hampshire Law Review.